How do you get there from the home page?
IMHO, there was no need to 'fix' this...now folks need to navigate to 2 different pages. Plus, there are so few actual reviews posted on a daily basis meaning that when someone does finally post a review, it will likely not be seen by many people.
Personally, I think all you needed to do was to make sure people aren't spamming "multiple" threads for the same spa everyday AND maybe provide one button for people to quickly filter out all the spa ads...but no need for two separate pages, in the long run, this won't be effective.